Foreign Aid
The U.S. spends about $30 billion per year on foreign aid. Much of this money is wasted by corrupt governments and embezzled by foreign officials. Very little of the money is used for the intended purposes, and we receive almost no credit or appreciation from the people of these countries.
Why not make all foreign aid available only in American-manufactured products delivered by American ships and vehicles? A catalog of American products could be given to the governments, and they could order up to their aid limit. Items could include food, medical supplies and equipment, farming equipment, mining equipment, factory equipment, military equipment, construction equipment and supplies, etc. There is nothing these foreign countries could possibly need that could not be obtained from American manufacturers. Everything supplied would be obviously marked as coming from America.
Implementing this approach would create thousands of American jobs and stimulate our economy with no additional cost to the taxpayer. It would eliminate most of the waste of our aid money and benefit the citizens of the countries receiving the aid. It would benefit our economy rather than that of competing countries. Perhaps this would generate some credit and appreciation from the foreign citizens.Our problem is to get Congress to implement such an obvious and simple solution to our foreign-aid expenses.
DONALD L. GARREN
Lambsburg, Va.
Anonymous method
Thank you for doing away with the essentially completely anonymous method of commenting on your stories online ("To the readers," July 10). I do not fully endorse Facebook as the mechanism for authentication, but I certainly understand the business reasons for using it.
NORMAN HILL
Lewisville
Fear and paranoia
The July 13 story "GOP's light bulb idea goes dark" and the same day's letter "The greatness of the U.S." exemplify perfectly the fear and paranoia that prevent me from taking conservatives seriously.
The letter writer says, "… we don't like government telling us what food to eat, what light bulb to use or what air to breath." I could sort of understand that if the government were saying to eat slime, furnish our houses with strobe lights and breath air with a high methane content — but the government hasn't done anything of the sort.
I want my food to be inspected for safety — we've seen, in the news, what happens when it isn't. The aforementioned story points out that new standards for light bulbs mean that we'll pay less and use less energy for the same amount of light. Is that really worth fighting against? As for air — well, I'm just dumbfounded. "We don't like the government telling us what kind of air to breath"? Is there really someone who would prefer breathing polluted air? Really?
I could understand these "freedom fighters" if they were fighting rules that make life worse for Americans. But why are they always objecting to things that make life better for Americans?ROGER L. MACK
Winston-Salem
Both are taught
In the July 10 "Doonesbury" comic strip, cartoonist Garry Trudeau depicted a school where both evolution and creationism are taught. During the discussion of creationism, a student in this school asked the teacher to stop because he wanted "to get into a good college."
Calvary Baptist Day School students examine both evolution and creationism. Members of the Class of 2011 have been accepted to UNC Chapel Hill, Davidson College, Duke University, N.C. State, Wake Forest University, West Point, Wheaton College and Yale University (Mr. Trudeau's alma mater).
BILL WALTER
Winston-Salem
support his contention that most is wasted or embezzled. I don't doubt that some is, however. Also, a fair portion of foreign aid is spent on US goods and services.
ReplyDeleteLTE2: The new Forum format has certainly changed the tone of some of the discussions, as it appears to have largely driven bigots and trolls back under their rocks.
LTE3: Yes, we do need rules, thus we have food inspections, as noted by the LTE writer. However, some rules are debatable, with CFB's being an example. The bulbs do indeed save electricity as they are much more efficient at generating light instead of heat. I use them in my households (yes, plural). But, they contain toxic mercury, so disposal is a concern, as is clean-up after breakage. Also, incandescent bulbs' heat generation is actually useful during cold weather. Regulation with an agenda is a concern, a glaring example is the Administration's usage of the NLRB to enable labor unions to pressgang employees into membership.
LTE4: Sorry, evolution is a fact. Teaching creationism turns our existence into a parlor trick by God. We human beings are the most complex known structures in the universe. We are tge product of a process that started with the Creation of the universe 13.7 billion years ago. The reduce our existence to the snap of celestial fingers diminishes God. Well sort of. Actually, 13.7 billion years is just a snap of the fingers in eternity. It's all relative, as Einstein might say. The LTE writer is correct, however. Being taught creationism does not disqualify applicants for admission to good colleges.
Good afternoon folks! Hope all the regulars are doing well and will join in!
ReplyDeleteLTE 1: Actually, foreign aid is mostly comprised of the items mentioned. Money makes up a smaller portion than Mr. Garren realizes.
LTE 2: You don't see the nastiness, but then again, you're not seeing much of anything. The use of FB prohibits me from posting while I'm at my office.
LTE 3: I also have noticed that the most conservative people I know are also the most paranoid with the exception of a person I worked with who was schizophrenic (he had no political persuasion). I agree there needs to be enforced standards for clean air and water as well as safe food. A strong economy is difficult to achieve if everyone has cancer. I'm switching over to LED's myself.
LTE 4: They may both be taught at Calvary, but rest assured, creationism has no place in the biology curriculum at any of the fine colleges mentioned. Creationism isn't falsifiable, therefore it is not science.
BTw..GiGi: if you're out there, i sent you an email about getting together ("Greetings from dotnet") when you left me you email address. Hope you got it
Greetings Staballoy, Dotnet, and all my long lost forum friends,
ReplyDeleteLately I haven't been able to participate on the regular forum, but I miss the ability to do so. Even if I eventually crack and sign up for a facebook account, I will not use it to post on the forum. I'm bummed, but it's the Journal's property and what can I do? With regards to LTE2, it seems participation has dropped meaningfully, but it doesn't mean there aren't just as many page views (which I believe is the goal?).
Dotnet, I never received an email from you, I just checked again, but it may have gone in my spam box! I was just in NC with a big birthday party to manage, and my sister in law V was going to come but could not due to work. She's too new in her job to ask for time off work, but will be down soon! Please email me again at contactdcgigi@gmail.com ! I'll watch the account super carefully.
I hope everyone is doing well, and hope to read from the old board participants soon.
Best regards.
Stab, Thanks for the DotNet and Gigi fix. About to go into withdrawal. I don't know if the Journal will get as many eyeballs. I too like seeing Roblo and McCavity go at it. I guess time will tell. I do understand that some comments had increasingly mean.
ReplyDeleteMean? I know macavity well. He told me that he loves Roblo like a brother, and hunter and knothead/burrhead/knucklehead as well. He even pines for our prodigal JohnG. Brothers all.
ReplyDeleteI mean, Cain(iac) did love Abel, didn't he?
Seems my post disappeared so I'll try it again.
ReplyDeleteHi everyone, I guess the Journal decided they didnt want the left's point of view anymore so they shut down everyone! Maybe they will revisit their decision as I'm sure many of the old group will be limited in when they/we can post and view because of employers site restrictions. Plus I bet advertisers have noticed a hit. Dad is fighting cancer and going thru chemo so prayers welcomed from those so inclined.
I Agree with much of what Mr Garren said. It would be nice if our aid was in the form of American made or American provided products, but those in high power, even the Red Cross, say money is best because it quickly gets spending money in the peoples pockets so their economy gets kick started. Plus it is easier for an enterprising politician to hide money in a briefcase (or freezer) than a bulldozer is. It's kinda like, give to the people and put my name on the check.
Mr Hill, there are some not so nice people out there so I like the completely anonymous method of commenting.
Mr Mack follows the typical left mantra, if they think its ok…end of discussion. If anyone disagrees too bad.
See what I mean? I no sooner mention Roblo, than up he pops. Amazing what?
ReplyDeleteMy grandmother, a poor farmer's wife who had memorized both the bible and most of Shakespeare, was a fount of wise advice. Here are a couple:
1. Be careful what you wish for, for you shall surely get it.
2. Never say the name of the devil, because he always comes when called.
Was she right?
Oh, robby boy, my brother, welcome back. Things have been so dull without you.
ReplyDeleteI love your first post, because it is riddled with nonsense, but let's get things off on the right foot by focusing on your wise comments about foreign aid. One question, multiple choice. This is a test (no fair Googling - you wouldn't cheat, would you?):
US foreign aid represents what percentage of the annual national budget?
a. 40%
b. 31%
c. 24%
d. 18%
e. Some other outrageous amount, between 18 and 40%.
Hi dotnet, Gigi, O. T. Rush, Wordly, Roblo!
ReplyDeleteWell, O. T., you said macavity loves Rob like a brother, so devil he must not be. Good guys both of you be.
Rob, my best wishes and prayers for your father. As you know, I take care of my dad, so I am with you in spirit.
O. T., Cain(iac) had an odd way of expressing his affection for Abel. My take on that is that God telegraphed His outlook on the DP: He did not inflict the DP on Cain for the murder. And yes, I know the story is allegorical, but the lesson remains.
Rob, you have some good points re foreign aid. I suspect that some of our aid end up in Cayman Island bank accounts is not lost on our policymakers. A bit of palm-greasing is necessary in some places.
Gigi, get V and yourself and Jason down here, and let's put together a Readers' Forum meet and greet.
And folks, pass the word as you can that all Forum participants are welcome. Glad to see several of you here.
O. T., thank you for furnishing the banished ambience that we prized in the Reader's Forum. No offense to Rob, but I'm still laughing.
ReplyDeleteAll the percentages you list in your multiple guess test appear high to me.
Programming note: I've said this in other posts, but if you're having trouble posting, sign out, and when you sign in, be sure that the "Keep Me Signed In" box is UNCHECKED. Checking it seems to block posting, churlishly wouldn't let me post to my own damn blog :(
ReplyDeleteHey GiGi!
ReplyDeleteI just sent you an email. Hopefully it will get through this time.
No fair helping our brother robby, Stab. This could be the difference between his getting into Harvard or being banished to the University of Cliff Diving in Acapulco, MX.
ReplyDeleteThe Cain(iac) and Abel story is my all time favorite, because I love detective stories, and it is the 2nd detective story of all time.
The first, of course, is when god notices that Adam & Eve have taken up wearing Alexander Julian Originals fig leaves. it's a good one, because it involves a snake - always good plotting, but really difficult to cast. Jack Nicholson is great, but can he really do the serpent?
But when god looks around and notices that Abel's picture is on a milk carton - ah - now we're headed into the noir world right off the bat.
So god assumes the role of detective:
And the LORD said unto Cain, Where is Abel thy brother? And he said, I know not: Am I my brother's keeper?
Classic wise guy. Why's everybody always picking' on me...Charley Brown...he's a clown...
And he (god) said, What hast thou done? the voice of thy brother's blood crieth unto me from the ground.
OK, we've already got our first CSI analyzing blood traces.
So now god switches to the DA role:
And now art thou cursed from the earth, which hath opened her mouth to receive thy brother's blood from thy hand.
Pretty impressive closing argument.
And now god becomes judge and hands down a good, hardcore Republican sentence:
When thou tillest the ground, it shall not henceforth yield unto thee her strength; a fugitive and a vagabond shalt thou be in the earth.
And then we get a Cain(iac) genealogy, which continues ad infinitum right down to our latest symbolic demon, Casey Anthony. What more can you ask?
Who says the bible is fiction?
Well OT or should I say macavity since you feel my post was full of nonsense I feel I was pretty close to the mark, and as my post was not about the dollar amount of our foreign aid or even the rightness or wrongness of such aid I'm not gunna get into a debate as to how much aid is in the budget or the percentage. Since it would be hard to guess how many and how bad worldwide disasters might be for any future year I doubt any budgeted amount would be correct. The gist of my post was aid might be better if given in American products. That way countries get the things they need, our workers and companies get a benefit, also goods are harder and less attractive to steal than cash, or their at least harder to hide!
ReplyDeleteOK, gloves off.
ReplyDeleteAs usual, robby boy, my beloved brother, evades the question and goes off on a tangent. Look, bro, if you want to go to Harvard you've got to pass the entrance exam first.
As to the tangent, you seem to have confused "foreign aid", a recurring phenomenon, with "humanitarian aid", an unpredictable event which has nothing to do with recurring "foreign aid".
And as to the "gist", if you had been paying attention earlier you might have learned that much of US "foreign aid" is indeed given in American products and services.
Not that that means anything. For some years now we have been sending huge amounts of food to famine stricken Somalia. The Somalian warlords and other thugs have been grabbing the shipments at ground zero and selling what they couldn't use for themselves to the highest bidder.
In a truly ironic twist, Somalian pirates have actually been donating some of the goods that they have seized on the high seas to relief efforts in Haiti.
It's a complicated world, robby boy. You really need the Harvard education to understand it. So answer the question.
If you can't, take comfort in the fact that the Acapulco cliff divers never think about anything other than getting those hot tourista babes into bed. If that is your ambition, go for it.
I feel renewed.
ReplyDeleteHello Wordly!
ReplyDeleteYes, we can go home again :)